Human rights and cultural organizations denounce prosecution of filmmakers Ertuğrul Mavioğlu and Çayan Demirel in joint letter
More than 40 human rights, cultural and film organizations signed a joint letter that condemn prosecution of documentary filmmakers Ertuğrul Mavioğlu and Çayan Demirel for their documentary Bakur and asking for the charges against the duo be dropped.
The letter, signed by rights groups including Platform for Independent Journalism (P24), PEN International, the International Press Institute (IPI), Reporters Without Borders (RSF), the Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ) is addressed to Culture and Tourism Minister Numan Kurtulmuş and Justice Minister Abdulhamit Gül.
It was published on 28 May, a day before Mavioğlu and Demirel appeared before a penal court in the southeastern province of Batman in a trial where they are charged with “spreading propaganda for a terrorist organization.” The court ruled to accept requests from Mavioğlu and Demirel to be exempted from attending the future hearings and adjourned the trial until 23 October.
At the hearing, lawyers for Mavioğlu and Demirel also presented to the court an expert opinion prepared by freedom of expression group Article 19.
May 28, 2018
Minister of Culture and Tourism of the Republic of Turkey
İsmet İnönü Bulvarı No:32 06100
Emek Ankara, Turkey
Minister of Justice
Kızılay Mahallesi, Milli Müdafa Cd., 06420
Cc: Turkish National Commission for UNESCO
Dear Prof. Dr. Numan Kurtulmuş and Minister Abdulhamit Gül,
We, the undersigned cultural and human rights organizations, call upon the Public Prosecutor’s Office of Batman to drop charges immediately against filmmakers Çayan Demirel and Ertuğrul Mavioğlu and to cease efforts to criminalize the film and its makers. We also urge the Ministry of Culture and Tourism of the Republic of Turkey and the General Directorate of Cinema to support both filmmakers and to advocate for charges against them to be dropped. The upcoming court proceeding against Demirel and Mavioğlu comes at a time when artists, academics and journalists in Turkey are being criminalized in alarming numbers for the peaceful exercise of their free speech.
On May 29, Demirel and Mavioğlu will appear in front of the Batman 2nd Assize Court. Both filmmakers stand charged with disseminating propaganda in favor of a terrorist organization under Article 7/2 of Law no. 3713 on Counter-Terrorism for their documentary film Bakurand face up to five years of imprisonment if found guilty. The feature length documentary, shot in the summer and fall months of 2013, shows the daily life of PKK members in three different camps in southeast Turkey. The timing of both the filming and production of Bakur coincided with the peace talks between the Turkish government and the PKK to end a 40-year conflict during which a ceasefire was in place.
As the peace talks unraveled, Bakur was scheduled to premiere at the 34th Istanbul Film Festival on May 5, 2015, but on that day, the İstanbul Foundation for Culture and Arts (İKSV) cancelled the screening. The film was subsequently shown in numerous other international and national festivals, but two years later, on December 20, 2017, the filmmakers were accused of disseminating terrorist propaganda and giving “legitimacy to the terrorist organization PKK/KCK’s methods of using force, violence or threats.” If found guilty, this would be the first time that filmmakers in Turkey would face a prison sentence due to a film, a dangerous precedent for the status of freedom of expression. However, as an attack on peaceful exercise of the right to free expression in Turkey, Bakur is not an isolated case. Numerous journalists, scholars, writers and artists are currently facing similar criminal prosecutions.
The right to freedom of expression, whether in a film, newspaper, painting, or peaceful protest is an essential part of a functioning democratic society and the development of vibrant cultures. Artistic expression can play a productive role in addressing conflicts, reconciling former enemies, and can contribute to developing trust between individuals and groups that have experienced protracted conflicts. Turkey has affirmed this and made international commitments to uphold these freedoms, having ratified, both the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) and the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). The right to freedom of expression is also protected in the Turkish Constitution (Article 26), which states that, “Everyone has the right to express and disseminate his/her thoughts and opinions by speech, in writing or in pictures or through other media, individually or collectively.” Based on these commitments, Turkey can only exclude controversial works from the protections granted to free speech in exceptional and strictly defined circumstances where national security is under threat because the work would constitutes “an incitement to discrimination, hostility or violence” as expressed in the article 20 of the ICCPR. Further, based on the Principle 6 of the Johannesburg Principles, the expression may only be punished as a threat to national security if a government can demonstrate that it is intended or likely to incite violence.
Bakur does not incite discrimination, hostility or violence, but rather documents an attempt to reach a peace agreement after a decades-long conflict between the PKK and the Turkish government. Its purpose, as stated in the film’s own trailer, is “to invite its viewers to reflect on a war that has been continuing for decades and give an insightful look on its main subject, the PKK.” Such creative work is clearly and unequivocally protected in accordance with Turkey’s domestic and international commitments. Turkey must uphold its domestic and international commitments to protect freedom of expression and ensure that artists are free to create without fear.
- Adil Soz – International Foundation for Protection of Freedom of Speech
- AG DOK
- Albanian Media Institute
- Arterial Network
- Articolo 21
- Association of Caribbean Media Workers
- Bytes for All
- Cartoonists Rights Network International (CRNI)
- Committee for Relevant Art (CORA)
- City of Asylum – Pittsburgh
- Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ)
- Danish PEN
- Documentarist İstanbul Belgesel Günleri
- English PEN
- European Documentary Network (EDN)
- European Grassroots Antiracist Movement – EGAM
- Federation of European Film and TV Directors (FERA)
- Freedom Forum
- Independent Journalism Center – Moldova
- Index on Censorship
- International Partnership for Human Rights (IPHR)
- International Press Institute (IPI)
- Mediacentar Sarajevo
- Media, Entertainment and Arts Alliance
- Media Institute of Southern Africa
- National Union of Somali Journalists
- Norwegian PEN
- Pacific Island News Association
- PEN America
- PEN Canada
- PEN International
- P24 (Platform for Independent Journalism)
- Reporters Without Borders
- Safe+Secure (DocSociety)
- South East Europe Media Organisation (SEEMO)
- South East European Network for Professionalization of Media Sundance Institute
- Syrian Center for Media and Freedom of Expression
- The Beverly Rogers, Carol C. Harter Black Mountain Institute
- The Independent Filmmaker Project (IFP)
- The International Exile Film Festival – Sweden
- VdÜ e.V. – Die Literaturübersetzer
- Vigilance for Democracy and the Civic State
- VS – Verband Deutscher Schriftstellerinnen und Schriftsteller World Association of Community Radio Broadcasters (AMARC)